An ETF return calculator gives you several numbers at once, and it isn’t always obvious which one to look at. This guide walks through the three views in order (the after-tax ranking, the risk view and the break-even), using one simple example: $1,000 held for 10 years. Follow along in the calculator, then swap in your own numbers.
Start by entering these in the left-hand panel. They are the calculator’s standard settings, with a $1,000 lump sum held for 10 years.
| Assumption | Value |
|---|---|
| Amount invested | $1,000 |
| Holding period | 10 years |
| Marginal tax rate | 30% |
| Inflation (CPI) | 3.00% |
| Mortgage (offset) rate | 6.50% |
| ETF capital growth | 8.00% p.a. |
| ETF dividend yield (ASX 200 default) | 3.80% |
| Physical gold growth | 8.00% p.a. |
| Term deposit rate | 5.00% |
| Capital gains tax | 50% discount (current law) |
With a lump sum and no contributions the results scale in proportion: $100,000 gives figures 100 times larger.
With Risk model: OFF, the summary panel ranks each option by its after-tax gain over the 10 years. This is the first thing to read: what each option is projected to earn once tax is taken out.
| Rank | Option | After-tax gain | Final value |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | ETF (shares) | $1,285 | $2,285 |
| 2nd | Physical gold | $985 | $1,985 |
| 3rd | Offset account | $877 | $1,877 |
| 4th | Term deposit | $411 | $1,411 |
Offset “final value” is cash retained plus mortgage interest avoided.
Why the ETF leads here:
Click Risk model: ON. The risk view applies a simple haircut to each option’s positive gain, using multiplier = (10 − risk score) ÷ 10. The default scores are offset 0, term deposit 1, ETF 4 and gold 5.
| Rank | Option | After-tax gain | Risk score | Multiplier | Risk-view gain |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | Offset account | $877 | 0 | ×1.00 | $877 |
| 2nd | ETF (shares) | $1,285 | 4 | ×0.60 | $771 |
| 3rd | Physical gold | $985 | 5 | ×0.50 | $493 |
| 4th | Term deposit | $411 | 1 | ×0.90 | $370 |
The offset account loses nothing to the haircut because its return is a guaranteed saving on mortgage interest. The ETF keeps 60% of its projected gain and drops to second, $106 behind.
Scroll down to the Break-even & What-If Analyser, choose ETF (Stocks) and Show all allowed levers. Instead of asking you to forecast a return, it works backwards: what capital growth rate would put the ETF back in first place under the risk view?
So with a 6.5% mortgage, a risk-adjusted ETF needs to deliver roughly 12.8% a year in total (growth plus dividends, before tax) to match a guaranteed, tax-free 6.5%. That is the gap the after-tax ranking in Step 1 hides. For a deeper look at break-even thinking, including different mortgage rates and tax brackets, see What return do I need to beat my offset account?
The risk scores are editable, and the break-even moves with them. The 9% figure comes directly from the default ETF score of 4. Changing only that score gives these break-even growth rates (all other inputs as above):
| ETF risk score | Multiplier | Break-even capital growth | Total incl. 3.8% dividends |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | ×1.00 | 5.32% | 9.12% |
| 1 | ×0.90 | 6.02% | 9.82% |
| 2 | ×0.80 | 6.83% | 10.63% |
| 3 | ×0.70 | 7.81% | 11.61% |
| 4 (default) | ×0.60 | 9.00% | 12.80% |
| 5 | ×0.50 | 10.49% | 14.29% |
Break-even = growth at which the ETF’s risk-view gain matches the offset account’s $877 over 10 years.
Two things stand out. With no haircut at all, the ETF only needs about 5.3% growth to lead, which is why after-tax rankings tend to favour shares. And each extra point of risk discount adds roughly 0.7 to 1.5 percentage points to the return the ETF must deliver. How much certainty you are willing to give up is doing most of the work.
On these assumptions, yes: $1,285 against $877 per $1,000 over 10 years. That ranking treats the ETF’s projected return as certain. Once a risk haircut is applied, the offset account leads unless the ETF grows at about 9% a year or more.
Every dollar in the offset saves mortgage interest at a known rate, and that saving is not taxed. Its default risk score is 0, so its gain is counted in full. You can change any score if you see it differently.
They can. Under the 2027 rules setting, the calculator taxes the inflation-adjusted gain at a minimum 30% instead of applying the 50% discount. Switch the CGT setting and re-run the break-even to see the effect for your inputs. See the 2027 CGT changes explained.
No. It is a calculation tool that shows how outcomes respond to assumptions. For decisions that matter, speak to a licensed financial adviser or registered tax agent.